GWR did try to place broad gauge locos elsewhere

Published: 03:26PM Feb 1st, 2012

THE article on ‘safeguarded’ locos that were then wantonly destroyed (Dec) was informative, but states that destruction of the two broad gauge locos at Swindon in 1906 was done by Stanier whilst Churchward was on leave. This was not the case.

The National Archives hold the Minute Book for the GWR Locomotive Committee meeting of July 22, 1903, in which it is recorded: “Mr Churchward reported that (due to space being required at Swindon) that having regard for the interest attached
to the two engines, they be offered to the South Kensington Museum and the committee recommended that an effort be made to dispose of them in this manner.”

Two and a half years later, in the minutes of the meeting of December 20, 1905, it states: “Ref minute 19 of 22/7/03: The Locomotive Superintendent reported that the old broad gauge engines … had been offered to several institutions without success and upon his recommendation, the committee agreed that they should be broken up.”

It would appear that no-one elsewhere had the sense to realise that those were important items. Space at Swindon was at a premium then.

I should also note that at that point of time, any Stanier involved in the destruction (and I can find no record of this) would have been William Stanier’s father – W H Stanier (also a William), who was chief clerk at Swindon, and not the later loco engineer, who was working as a running superinten-dent at Paddington/Old Oak Common at that time.

Otherwise, I found the article to be an interesting essay in railway company short-sightedness.

GWR Loco Steward,
Hstorical Model Railway Society,
Alsager, Cheshire

Our thanks to Mr Lewis for uncovering this little-known archive information and to Andrew Hemming of Dumbarton for a similar letter. – Ed

Responses to “GWR did try to place broad gauge locos elsewhere”

Current Issue: Nov 2015

Issue Nov 2015

The RM archive: Back for the Future
New heritage branch line opens
Electrification costs triple for Great Western
Exclusive DVD offers
Christmas gifts guide
Chiltern begins Evergreen 3 services

John Vaughan: Behind the lens
Before the HSTs
Welsh narrow gauge in 1949


Buy this issue now

• Next issue on sale: December 2, 2015

Issue 1376

Issue 1376
Nov 2015

Britain's best-selling rail title

Subscribe and get this issue

Other Letters

FGW rebranding just a bold marketing exercise

YOUR report that FGW is to re-brand to GWR (October 2015) provided a moment of fantasy. 

Read More »

Re-nationalisation could be value for money

YOUR piece on possible re-nationalisation of the railways makes a number of assumptions which are open to question. 

Read More »

View all...


Related magazines:

Heritage Railway magazine Rail Express magazine Old Glory magazine

Use our handy tool to find your nearest stockist!
Find your nearest Stockist

Read on-line as a digital issue:

Read on Android

Read on an iPad

Available on Pocket Mags

Advertising Deadline:

December 2015 issue - November 20, 2015
January 2016 issue - December 17, 2015

Book advertising here

Next Issue Out:

December 2, 2015